UK Visit
WN0V0995ed1AsmaatICS_red3
Photo © Benedict Parsons

UN Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief concludes Visit to UK in June 2007

Index

UN Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief concludes Visit to UK

UN News Centre: BRITISH COUNTER-TERRORISM LAWS SPARK CONCERN FROM UN EXPERT ON RELIGIOn (June 2007)

UN Countries Visit Report examining religious freedom in the UK published in February 2008, ahead of UN Human Rights Council discussions (as yet unscheduled)

Web-site links

UN Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief concludes Visit to UK

 (Below is the text of a press release, issued by the UN on 15 June 2007)

 Paragraph Index (added):

  1. Introduction
  2. Rapporteur's mandate
  3. Rapporteur's UK itinerary
  4. Reasons for visit: assessing diversity vs individual freedom, immigration policy, Muslims post 7/7, counter-terrorism legislation, lessons from N Ireland
  5. N Ireland -lessons for counter-terrorism
  6. Muslim focus: stop-and-search, religious profiling, non-disclosure of information related to terrorism a criminal offence
  7. N Ireland: religious inequalities in labour market,housing, education, policing and criminal justice agencies; gender inequality; concerns of religious minorities.
  8. UK grassroots: schools -religious education and collective worship; religious symbols; blasphemy laws and interfaith dialogue; balancing of competing rights with regard to sexual orientation regulations and freedom of conscience
  9. Rigid scrutiny of asylum claims
  10. Converts and community of their former religion
  11. Tribute

1 Asma Jahangir, the Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief of the United Nations Human Rights Council, made the following statement on 15 June 2007 in London at the end of her visit to the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland:

Back to Index

2 “In July 2004, I was appointed Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief by the United Nations Commission on Human Rights. My mandate is to examine incidents and governmental actions in all parts of the world which are inconsistent with the provisions of the Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief, and to recommend remedial measures for such situations. In the framework of my mandate, I receive individual complaints which are documented in my communications report. Furthermore, I undertake visits to several countries per year where I can get first-hand impressions and develop some issues in more depth.

Back to Index

3 At the invitation of the Government, I have visited the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland from 4 to 15 June 2007. During my visit I had the opportunity to meet the Prime Minister, senior politicians and Government officials responsible for religious matters. In addition, I talked with representatives of religious and belief organizations, non-governmental organizations of relevance to my mandate as well as academics and individuals. These talks were held in London, Birmingham, Bradford, Glasgow and Belfast. Furthermore, I visited a school, a prison and an immigration removal center.

Back to Index

4 The reasons for conducting the UK visit were manifold. Firstly, the situation in the United Kingdom has a special significance and interest for my mandate. The United Kingdom has historically been home and safe harbour for those persecuted on religious grounds. It features a multi-cultural and multi-religious society, which poses a number of challenges in celebrating its diversity and yet ensuring that individual freedoms are protected, too. New pressures have arisen to review its immigration policies and I intended to examine whether these have affected victims of religious persecution who are coming from abroad. Secondly, there have been concerns about the situation of Muslims across the country in the aftermath of the tragic terrorist attacks of 7 July 2005. Consequently, I wanted to assess the situation in view of counter-terrorism legislation and the pressures on the society as a whole. Finally, the recent developments in Northern Ireland are of particular interest to my mandate.

Back to Index

5 I am very much impressed by the depth of knowledge and the ability of the UK Government in responding to difficult situations and tackling the contentious issues involved. There is a great wealth of experience in the United Kingdom in dealing with religious tensions and terrorist acts carried out under the cover of religion. There is a significant potential to draw some “lessons learnt” from the response to the sectarian divide in Northern Ireland and to address new challenges in devising counter-terrorism measures. In this regard, I would like to emphasize that the protection and promotion of fundamental freedoms and human rights is vital for any democratic society.

Back to Index

6 Despite the overall respect for human rights and their value in this country, there are a few areas of concern with regard to freedom of religion or belief. Subsequent to recent terrorist attacks and threats, laws have been introduced which undermine the human rights of all and which are largely perceived to target the Muslim population in the United Kingdom. A discriminatory application of stop-and-search powers and religious profiling may ultimately prove to be counterproductive. Moreover, whilst I am conscious of the fact that States are obliged to take effective measures in combating terrorist attacks, I have received allegations of the abuse of counter-terrorism laws and in particular of provisions which make the failure to disclose information about acts of terrorism a criminal offence.

Back to Index

7 I have to admit that my stay in Northern Ireland was particularly impressive for me. After decades of violence, which claimed more than 3,500 lives on religious/political grounds, there seems to be now hope for a shared future. There are promising initiatives which seek to cross the sectarian divide among the Christians, both on political and on grassroots levels. However, there remain several contentious areas such as religious inequalities in the labour market, housing, education, policing and criminal justice agencies. It is also important not to forget the concerns of religious minorities in Northern Ireland. Furthermore, it may be useful to take into account the perspectives of believers who are dispassionate about their faith and of secularists or humanists as well as of women. While there is no legal discrimination against women, yet many of them are in a vulnerable situation within their own communities. I believe that equality must be all-encompassing and the argument that traditions should override the rights of women is unacceptable.

Back to Index

8 On a general level in the United Kingdom, further issues of concern relate to the situation in schools concerning religious education and collective worship, religious symbols, blasphemy laws and interfaith dialogue. The balancing of competing rights may also be an issue of controversial debate, for example with regard to sexual orientation regulations and freedom of conscience. I am aware of the differences concerning the legal and institutional frameworks in England/Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland; in my report I intend to discuss some of these aspects in greater detail.

Back to Index

9 World politics also has its repercussions at the domestic level, for example the impact of developments in the Middle East on the situation of the Jewish community in the United Kingdom. Furthermore, the number of asylum seekers has dropped dramatically in recent years, including those applying on grounds of religious persecution. Asylum claims are subject to rigid scrutiny and few applications are successful in the initial decision. In this regard, I have received reports that very demanding criteria need to be met in order to obtain asylum.

Back to Index

10 Finally, I was saddened to meet converts who face problems with the community of their former religion. While the right to change one's religion is recognised by international human rights standards, some people seem to accept a conversion only when it involves a change into their own religion. Such an approach does not acknowledge diversity and infringes on freedom of religion or belief. In this regard, let me emphasize that theistic, non-theistic and atheistic beliefs as well as the right not to profess any religion or belief are protected.

Back to Index

11 I would like to thank everyone I met during my mission for the candidness with which they were willing to openly engage in the exchange of minds. Challenges are not unknown to the people of the United Kingdom and I have felt the endeavour to always take the discussion a step forward. My forthcoming country report to the Human Rights Council will deal with several issues concerning my mandate in more depth and it will also include conclusions and recommendations.”

Back to Index

 ENDS

This is not an official record. The actual Countries Visit Report for the Human Rights Council can be accessed via the web-link at the top of this page or by using the navigation bar at the left margin.

Country visit reports can be read at www.ohchr.org/english/issues/religion/visits.htm

Annual reports can be accessed at www.ohchr.org/english/issues/religion/annual.htm.

Concerns can be conveyed to freedomofreligion@ohchr.org.

The site www.ohchr.org/english/issues/religion/complaints.htm contains helpful information on how to prepare a submission.

Back to Index

 

Web Design

BRITISH COUNTER-TERRORISM LAWS SPARK CONCERN FROM UN EXPERT ON RELIGION

New York,Jun 15 2007  6:00PM

Although the United Kingdom possesses deep knowledge and a “great wealth of experience” in handling religious tensions and terrorist acts carried out for religious purposes, a United Nations independent expert today voiced concern over laws which have been promulgated following recent terrorist attacks.

Such laws are widely believed to target the UK’s Muslim population and “undermine the human rights of all,” AsmaJahangir, the Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief, said in a statement issued in London after wrapping up an 11-day visit to the country.

“A discriminatory application of stop-and-search powers and religious profiling may ultimately prove to be counterproductive,” she added.

While she understood that States were obliged to adopt measures to thwart terrorism, Ms. Jahangir also noted that she has heard allegations of abuses of counter-terrorism laws, particularly of the provisions which criminalize the failure to disclose information about terrorist acts.

During her visit to the UK, Ms. Jahangir met with Prime Minister Tony Blair, senior Government officials, politicians, non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and academics, while she also toured a school, a prison and an immigration removal centre.

The Special Rapporteur said she was “particularly impressed” by her experience in Northern Ireland, which has witnessed over 3,500 deaths in the past four decades due to religious and political violence.

“There seems to be now hope for a shared future,” she said, referring to “promising initiatives” seeking to bridge the sectarian divide between Protestants and Catholics.

But Ms. Jahangir pointed out that several problems, including religious inequalities in employment, housing and policing, remain in Northern Ireland.

Ms. Jahangir will forward her report on the UK, including recommendations, to the UN Human Rights Council – set up last year to replace the much-criticized Commission on Human Rights.

In a related development, the 47-member Council continued its fifth session in Geneva today, where it held consultations to prepare for various proposals, including one relating to a “universal periodic review” mechanism to monitor the rights records of Member States, which must be decided by next Monday.

On Sunday, the body will hold informal consultations where the Council President plans to distribute a revised text on institution-building measures.
 

ENDS

For more details go to UN News Centre at http://www.un.org/news
To listen to news and in-depth programmes from UN Radio go to:
http://radio.un.org/  

Back to Index  
 

[Home] [Introduction] [International Freedoms] [UN-OHCHR Rapporteurs] [UN-OHCHR Reports] [UK Religious Freedom Report] [UK Visit] [Human Rights] [UN Information] [Speeches & Addresses] [Links] [Contact Us]